Login Sign Up

eISSN : 2234-0793
pISSN : 1225-1151
Insert title here
Editor's & Reviewer's Guide

Editorial Regulation (Revised in April 2019)

 

The purpose of this regulation is to specify the editorial tasks concerning all publications issued by the Korean Society of Clothing and Textiles.

 

  1. The Society shall have an editorial committee to conduct editorial affairs.

1) The editorial committee consist of an editor-in-chief, associate chief editors and editorial board members.

2) The editor-in-chief is appointed by the president and also serves as editorial director.

3) The associate editor and the editorial board members are nominated by the nomination committee and appointed by the editor-in-chief so that professional and fair proceedings are conducted in consideration of specialty areas, affiliations, and regions.

4) The term of office for all editors and board members is two years and may be renewed.

  1. The Editorial Board performs the following duties:

1) The editorial board shall hold regular and occasional editorial board meeting and perform editorial affairs.

(1) Should the editor-in-chief or one-third of the editorial board members so request, a non-regular board meeting may be summoned.

(2) When necessary, subcommittee meetings or online meetings may be held in lieu of the regular or occasional editorial board meetings.

2) The editorial committee shall perform the following editorial tasks.

(1) Manage and conduct final review of submitted research manuscripts

(2) Review and revise the regulations related to editorial affairs

(3) Participate in planning editorial affairs

(4) Conduct other tasks related to editorial affairs

  1. Matters not specified in this regulation shall be applied in accordance with the customs of the academic community and similar regulations, and the editor-in-chief shall report the process and results to the editorial board and promptly revise regulations accordingly.

 

 

Regulation on the Review Process (Revised in August 2019)

 

The purpose of this regulation is to specify matters concerning the review of research manuscripts submitted to the Journal of the Korean Society of Clothing and Textiles (hereafter, manuscripts).

 

  1. Manuscript review is conducted through an online review system.

1) According to the content of the manuscript, the editor-in-chief will appoint a responsible editor among the editorial board members, and that editor will appoint reviewers.

2) The submitted manuscripts will be reviewed by two or more reviewers.

  1. The review criteria, review results, and publication decisions should be both equitable and rigorous and in accordance with the standard set forth below.

1) The criteria for manuscripts are originality, academic contribution, validity of results, interpretation of results, effective development of thesis, and appropriateness of references. Reviewers should judge the manuscript strictly and objectively in accordance with the criteria.

2) Review results shall be one of the following: 'publish as is', 'revision without re-review', 'revision with further review', and 'rejection'.

3) The publication decision will be made based on 2/3 or more of the reviewers' recommendation.

4) The final publication decision will be made by the responsible editor and the editorial board.

(1) If the reviewers recommend 'publish as is', the responsible editor can review the manuscript and ask for further revision. When that editor confirms the revision as satisfactory, the publication process should start.

(2) Even when the reviewers recommend 'publish as is', the responsible editor may ask the editorial board to re-examine the manuscript when a specific reason exists. In such event, the final publication decision shall be made by the editorial board.

  1. Appointed reviewers are obliged to conduct a fair review of the manuscript in accordance with this regulation.

1) Reviewers shall complete the review within 14 days after being invited to review.

2) If a reviewer does not complete the review within 30 days after being invited to review, the reviewer may be disinvited.

3) Reviews shall be anonymous and reviewers are expected to keep all aspects related to the review process and the review results confidential.

4) Reviewers shall observe the regulation when reviewing the manuscript, and should specifically mention reasons for their judgment and comments.

  1. The review or publication process will be undertaken only when a revised manuscript is submitted within three months of the review report. A manuscript that has not been revised within three months shall be judged to be rejected, unless there is a reason acceptable to the editorial board.
  2. Items not specified in this regulation shall be processed in accordance with the customs of the academic community and analogous regulations, and the editor-in-chief shall report the process and results to the editorial committee and promptly revise regulations accordingly.

     

    Results and criteria of manuscript evaluation

     

    Review Results

    Rejection

    Possible Judgment Following Further Review

    Publish as is

    May be published without further revision

     

    Revision without re-review

    Minor revisions that do not influence the decision of publica-tion are requested of the author. The responsible editor will examine the revision results.

    • Publish as is

    • Revision without re-review

    Revision with re-review

    Fundamental, or major revision is required. The reviewers will re-review the manuscript after revision is made.

    • Publish as is

    • Revision without re-review

    • Revision with re-review

    • Rejection

    Rejection

    Cannot be published in the journal because it either does not satisfy journal criteria or violates research ethics or regulations

     


  • 용어 변경











닫기    저장

·  ·  ·  ·